On Hillary and Bernie

Read the follow-up here.

Look, let’s get this out there once and for all: It’s not that I don’t think Bernie can win, it’s that I don’t want him to.

For some reason, that’s difficult for a lot of people to comprehend.

I am a progressive. I want the things Bernie promises for this country. I want universal health care, and free higher education, and reduced incarceration, and an end to the artificial redistribution of wealth into the pockets of the filthy rich.

But I also understand basic civics, and I read the news, so I know that the Republican party is simultaneously in shambles and completely entrenched in Congress.

Bernie Sanders has no plan for enacting his ambitious, domestic, legislative agenda other than “political revolution.” Vote for me, he says, and we’ll get the money out of politics and thereby force Congress to listen to the American people.

Putting aside the questionable idea that campaign finance reform is the only thing standing between the United States and truly representative politics (our politics was morally bankrupt long before Citizens United), we are not going to have a revolution in 2016. We are going to have a new president.

I know what a revolution looks like, and this election—using the complicated system of party delegates and the electoral college to choose the leader of one of the three branches of the government of the most powerful empire in the world—is not it. This is politics.

And if Sanders tries to force this Congress to do something like raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour nationally, the likely political result will be a government shutdown. Jeet Heer summed this point up well at The New Republic last night:

The great difficulty Sanders faces is that given the reality of the American political system (with its divided government that has many veto points) and also the particular realities of the current era (with an intensification of political polarization making it difficult to pass ambitious legislation through a hostile Congress and Senate), it is very hard to see how a “political revolution” could work.

This is not to say that the presidency is unimportant or cannot have revolutionary consequences. The accomplishments of President Obama, even in the last six years of a hostile Republican Congress, have been manifold. But that’s precisely the point. As Jonathan Chait writes at New York Magazine today:

Those areas in which a Democratic Executive branch has no power are those in which Sanders demands aggressive action, and the areas in which the Executive branch still has power now are precisely those in which Sanders has the least to say. The president retains full command of foreign affairs; can use executive authority to drive social policy change in areas like criminal justice and gender; and can, at least in theory, staff the judiciary. What the next president won’t accomplish is to increase taxes, expand social programs, or do anything to reduce inequality, given the House Republicans’ fanatically pro-inequality positions across the board.

I’m not, by nature, a pragmatist. I believe in thinking big, and I believe in thinking with our values. But I also believe in thinking about the fact that small policy changes have big impacts on people’s lives. They might bore most civilized people to tears, but debates about closing the Medicaid gap created by Republican governors’ refusal to cooperate with the Affordable Care Act are important because without healthcare coverage, people die.

So it matters to me that I simply do not believe that Bernie can deliver on his promise to enact “Medicare for all”-style universal health coverage. Normally, a president comes out with a plan slightly more ambitious than what they would settle for, and then he (always he) negotiates his way to the center. Bernie is not like that. Bernie does not have work-arounds, or plans for compromise, or any sense that it’s worth settling to get some people some healthcare because that’s lives saved. Time spent trying to force universal healthcare through a reluctant Congress—and pissing them off in the process—will mean fewer people insured than if Sanders simply focused on closing the Medicaid gap.

So while Hillary’s plans might be less ambitious and less progressive on most points, I believe that the actual ground that she will gain is greater than the actual ground that would be gained under a Sanders presidency.

Hillary thinks in work-arounds. She is, in many ways, the source of President Obama’s growing assertiveness in the use of executive orders. She is smart, and she is ruthless, and she is good at politics, and I am tired of people acting like that’s a bad thing when somebody is fighting for a better country.

Which brings me to my last point.

I am voting for Hillary because I like her.


 Jacqui is a terrible dinner party guest—she only knows how to talk about politics and religion. On a typical Friday night, she can be found binge-watching her current Netflix show of choice, playing Civilization: The Board Game and drinking <$8 bottles of champagne.

276 thoughts on “On Hillary and Bernie

  1. The follow-up clears the opinions of the original posting:
    https://bottlemagazine.com/2016/01/25/on-hillary-and-bernie-part-ii/
    Both articles are heartfelt and I agree with many points, I am currently working (volunteer) for the local Ohio Democratic Party and I understand the need for unity in an overall goal to assure a Democratic president. truly feel that Bernie has a idealistic goal for our country and the HC does also just with a lesser degree of intensity. I want the ideals of Bernie to succeed and will vote for him, this does not mean I do not value HC, I do, but to a lesser degree than Bernie. The argument about Bernie being so far-a-field is probably correct but I hate the fact that we no longer have a choice in other than Dem. vs. Rep. The arguments come down to a belief that this country can never have an Independent Party ever again, I don’t agree. I would love to see a Bernie/Clinton or a Bernie/E.Warren ticket. This way we all can work towards the same goal, if it turns out to be a Clinton/Sanders or Clinton/Warren ticket, we win anyway. God help us if Trump get the win!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: The Younger Women In Democratic Politics Have Some Things To Say About This Primary | Free Books Zone

  3. Pingback: The Younger Women In Democratic Politics Have Some Things To Say About This Primary - Buzz And Gossip

  4. Pingback: The Younger Women In Democratic Politics Have Some Things To Say About This Primary – MYCANADIANBUSINESS.COM

  5. So the message is don’t vote to try and change things because it won’t change.

    Unfortunately you just provided a reason for people to not vote at all.

    Like

  6. Pingback: The Younger Women In Democratic Politics Have Some Things To Say About This Primary » Update News World

  7. Pingback: The Younger Women In Democratic Politics Have Some Things To Say About This Primary | Czaal News Feed

  8. Pingback: The Younger Women In Democratic Politics Have Some Things To Say About This Primary – DFW Politics

  9. Pingback: The Younger Women In Democratic Politics Have Some Things To Say About This Primary | ViralSpecials.com

  10. Pingback: Why the Democrats don’t deserve your support – Socialist Worker Online (blog) – Insurance For Us

  11. “She is smart, and she is ruthless, and she is good at politics, and I am tired of people acting like that’s a bad thing when somebody is fighting for a better country.” — How do you know she’s fighting for a better country and not just for power? How can you justify the big money from the big banks that are out to destroy the working class of this nation? How can you justify her anti-gay marriage stance, or her super-predator comments? It seems obvious that she will say anything to win an election, so how can you be sure that she’s got your best interest in mind? It’s hard for me to understand how anybody can argue against Bernie Sanders long, long record of being on the right side of things.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s